Key questions to ask a local SEO agency: Ask about track record (can they show results?), their specific monthly process, who owns your accounts, what the monthly report contains, and the minimum contract length and exit terms. Any agency unwilling to answer clearly is one to avoid.

Most businesses that have been burned by a local SEO agency say the same thing afterwards: “I didn’t know what to ask.”

The warning signs were there (vague deliverables, opaque reporting, locked accounts), but without the right questions, there was no way to see them. Asking the right things before you sign protects you from contracts that deliver nothing and lock you in for 12 months while they do it.

These 15 questions will tell you whether a local SEO agency is genuinely capable, honest about what they do, and working in your interest, or not.

In our experience speaking with Leicestershire business owners who have previously worked with agencies, most of the problems they encountered were avoidable if the right questions had been asked at the start.

Questions About Track Record
Questions About Their Process
Questions About Reporting and Access
Questions About Commercial Terms
Red Flag Answers to Watch For

Questions About Track Record {#track-record}

1. Can you show me results you have achieved for a business similar to mine?

This is the non-negotiable opening question. Any agency worth hiring should be able to show ranking improvements, GBP growth, or citation expansion for a business in a comparable niche and geography. Anonymised data is fine, but there must be data.

If an agency cannot produce evidence of results, they either have not achieved any or are unwilling to show them. Neither is acceptable.

2. Have you worked with businesses in my specific industry?

Local SEO for a plumber in Leicester is meaningfully different from local SEO for a dental practice in Loughborough. Industry-specific citation sources, category choices, and content approaches vary. An agency that has done work in your sector will move faster and make fewer errors.

3. Do you currently work with any of my direct competitors?

This question matters for two reasons. First, a conflict of interest: an agency actively trying to rank two competing plumbers for the same searches cannot give full effort to both. Second, it tells you whether they understand your market.

A reputable agency will be honest about existing clients in your niche. Our policy is a maximum of two clients per niche in any given service area. If the niche is full, we say so.

4. Can I speak to a current or recent client?

A genuine reference call, not a written testimonial, is the most reliable trust signal. An agency confident in their results will facilitate this willingly. Hesitation or vague offers to “pass on your details” is a warning sign.

Questions About Their Process {#process}

5. What does month one look like specifically?

The answer to this question separates agencies with a genuine process from those who improvise. A clear answer sounds like: “We start with a full audit of your GBP and existing citations, establish your canonical NAP, begin citation cleanup, and complete a keyword review for your primary service areas. By end of week two, you will have a strategy document.”

A vague answer sounds like: “We will get started on improving your online presence right away.” This means nothing.

6. How do you choose which citations to build?

Citation building is not simply submitting to as many directories as possible. Quality matters more than quantity. An agency should be building citations on directories that are relevant to your industry and location (national UK directories, local Leicestershire sources, and industry-specific platforms), not bulk-submitting to hundreds of low-authority sites that create noise rather than signal.

Ask them to name five specific directories they would build for your business in the first month. If they cannot, their process is not what they claim.

7. How do you approach Google Business Profile management?

GBP is the single highest-impact activity in local SEO. Whitespark’s research consistently shows GBP signals dominate Map Pack rankings above website authority, citations, and backlinks. An agency should have a clear monthly GBP process: post frequency, photo strategy, Q&A management, and category monitoring.

If GBP management feels like an afterthought in their pitch, it will be an afterthought in their delivery.

8. How do you generate reviews for clients?

The answer you want: a structured system: templated review request messages, a direct GBP review link, a follow-up process for recent customers, and monthly tracking of review velocity and average rating.

The answer you do not want: “We encourage clients to ask customers for reviews.” That is advice, not a service.

9. What does your content and on-page work involve?

If on-page SEO is included in the scope, ask for specifics. Which pages will they update? What keyword research informs the changes? Will they create new location pages, and if so, how will the content be unique for each area?

Generic answers about “improving your website” without specifics indicate either a lack of process or a lack of intent to do meaningful work.

10. How do you measure success?

Rankings are one part of the answer, but not the only part. Good agencies measure GBP engagement (calls, direction requests, website clicks from GBP), citation growth, review velocity, and organic traffic trends. If an agency can only talk about “improving your rankings” without defining how they will measure progress, they are not structured for accountability.

Questions About Reporting and Access {#reporting}

11. Will I own all my accounts and data?

This question has only one acceptable answer: yes. Your Google Business Profile, Google Analytics, and Google Search Console belong to you. An agency should operate within your accounts, not create their own versions and manage from there.

If you leave an agency that holds your accounts, you lose all historical data and potentially the accounts themselves. This is one of the clearest red flags in the industry.

12. What does your monthly report contain?

A good report is specific: keyword-by-keyword ranking movement, GBP insight data (calls, website clicks, direction requests), citation count and health score, new reviews received, and a concrete plan for the following month.

Ask to see an example report from a current client (anonymised). If they do not have one ready, or if the one they show you contains only graphs without written explanation, that is the level of reporting you will receive.

13. How often will we communicate, and who is my point of contact?

You should have a named account manager (not a support inbox) and a regular check-in cadence (monthly at minimum, ideally with a 30-minute call to review the previous month’s report). An agency that cannot commit to a named contact or a regular call is one where your account will drift between junior team members without continuity.

Questions About Commercial Terms {#commercial}

14. What is the minimum contract length, and what are the exit terms?

Standard initial commitments in the UK market are three to six months, enough time to demonstrate meaningful results, according to BrightLocal’s Local SEO Industry Survey. An 18-month minimum contract at a low monthly price is designed to lock you in when the service underdelivers. Contracts longer than 12 months require careful justification.

Ask what happens at the end of the contract: do you retain all work, accounts, and content? You should. An agency that retains your citation profiles or website content when you leave is using your assets as leverage.

15. What happens if the agreed deliverables are not met?

Every contract should specify what is included each month (GBP posts, citation builds, on-page updates) and what happens if those are not delivered. An agency confident in their ability to execute will have a clear answer. One that deflects or says “we always deliver” is not prepared to be held accountable.

Red Flag Answers to Watch For {#red-flags}

These responses should prompt serious hesitation regardless of price or promises:

“We guarantee first-page rankings”: No agency can guarantee Google rankings. Anyone who does is misrepresenting how search works.
“We use proprietary methods we cannot disclose”: Transparency is a basic professional expectation. Secrecy about methods usually protects the agency from scrutiny, not your results.
“Results will come quickly, usually within a few weeks”: Legitimate local SEO takes three to six months to produce visible Map Pack movement in most markets. Anyone promising rapid results is either misleading you or using tactics that will harm your profile.
“We manage everything through our own systems”: Your accounts belong to you. Any agency insisting on managing through their own accounts rather than yours is not acting in your interest.
“We cannot share client references at this stage”: A confident agency shares references. This response protects the agency from scrutiny, not your decision-making.

Use These Questions in Your Discovery Call

Print this list and work through it in your first meeting with any agency. A good agency will welcome the questions. They demonstrate you are a serious buyer who will hold them to account, and that is exactly the kind of client relationship good agencies want.

The answers you receive will tell you more about how an agency operates than any case study or proposal document.

Compare your options: agency vs freelancer →

See our full local SEO services →

15 Questions to Ask a Local SEO Agency

Table of Contents